Self storage units in Shirley, NY

38 spaces near Shirley

  • Find self storage closest to you. You could find storage within a few blocks.

storquest.com

StorQuest Self Storage

13 sizes available

4.4

393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY

1.5 mi

similarly priced

3'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$27/ mo

3'Ă—17'

starting at

 

$103/ mo

4'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$94/ mo

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$80/ mo

5'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$114/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$138/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$291/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$252/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$295/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$662/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$129/ mo

15'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$389/ mo

25'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$229/ mo

3'Ă—5' starting at

$27

devonsel...rage.com

Extra Space Storage

10 sizes available

4.9

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

4.7 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$54/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$113/ mo

10'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$164/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$187/ mo

10'Ă—14'

starting at

 

$162/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$314/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$369/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$458/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$469/ mo

15'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$605/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$54

storager...east.com

Storage R Us

8 sizes available

3.9

192 Frowein Rd East Moriches, NY

5.8 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$85/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$109/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$159/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$209/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$269/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$349/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$135/ mo

20'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$149/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$85

  • Find a space or unit that can store your personal items at a cheap cost.

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

7 sizes available

4.8

1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy Islandia, NY

15.8 mi

similarly priced

6'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$67/ mo

10'Ă—4'

starting at

 

$59/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$128/ mo

11'Ă—17'

starting at

 

$257/ mo

12'Ă—6'

starting at

 

$92/ mo

12'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$125/ mo

16'Ă—6'

starting at

 

$125/ mo

6'Ă—8' starting at

$67

lifestorage.com

Life Storage

12 sizes available

500 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

8.2 mi

similarly priced

4'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$44/ mo

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$55/ mo

5'Ă—6'

starting at

 

$68/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$92/ mo

10'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$135/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$184/ mo

10'Ă—11'

starting at

 

$199/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$253/ mo

10'Ă—16'

starting at

 

$269/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$316/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$377/ mo

20'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$269/ mo

10'Ă—5' starting at

$92

cubesmart.com

CubeSmart Self Storage

9 sizes available

4.7

640 Broadway Ave Holbrook, NY

10 mi

similarly priced

4'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$51/ mo

5'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$77/ mo

10'Ă—4'

starting at

 

$89/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$99/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$306/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$221/ mo

10'Ă—16'

starting at

 

$236/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$273/ mo

16'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$222/ mo

10'Ă—5' starting at

$99

  • Find large self storage spaces that can fit several items like furniture, beds, TVs, etc. All in a single unit.

istorage.com

iStorage Self Storage

23 sizes available

4.7

257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

7.9 mi

similarly priced

3'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$36/ mo

4'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$18/ mo

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$20/ mo

5'Ă—6'

starting at

 

$28/ mo

5'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$32/ mo

6'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$39/ mo

7'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$75/ mo

10'Ă—4'

starting at

 

$32/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$38/ mo

10'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$50/ mo

10'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$55/ mo

10'Ă—12'

starting at

 

$82/ mo

10'Ă—16'

starting at

 

$126/ mo

10'Ă—18'

starting at

 

$129/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$108/ mo

12'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$45/ mo

12'Ă—13'

starting at

 

$93/ mo

12'Ă—14'

starting at

 

$99/ mo

13'Ă—13'

starting at

 

$99/ mo

13'Ă—14'

starting at

 

$102/ mo

16'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$112/ mo

18'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

20'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$126/ mo

10'Ă—18' starting at

$129

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

4 sizes available

4.8

970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY

9.2 mi

similarly priced

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$98/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$238/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$317/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$138/ mo

10'Ă—20' starting at

$317

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

4 sizes available

4.9

510 Johnson Ave Bohemia, NY

11.4 mi

similarly priced

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$112/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$187/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$257/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$382/ mo

10'Ă—15' starting at

$257

  • Find medium to large self storage spaces that can fit items like furniture, beds, TVs, etc.

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

8 sizes available

4.8

14 Francis Mooney Dr Ridge, NY

8.2 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$115/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$162/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$257/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$300/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$273/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$382/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$167/ mo

15'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$420/ mo

10'Ă—5' starting at

$162

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

7 sizes available

4.8

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

10 mi

similarly priced

4'Ă—4'

starting at

 

$31/ mo

4'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$55/ mo

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$84/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$141/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$233/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$311/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$190/ mo

10'Ă—5' starting at

$141

primesto...roup.com

Prime Storage

12 sizes available

4.5

868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, NY

10.9 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$69/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$100/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$254/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$421/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$421/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$528/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$628/ mo

10'Ă—40'

starting at

 

$668/ mo

12'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$162/ mo

12'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$541/ mo

12'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$199/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$176/ mo

10'Ă—5' starting at

$100

  • Find self storage spaces that can fit most items in a bedroom or closet.

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

5 sizes available

4.8

3016 Express Dr S Islandia, NY

16.3 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$61/ mo

10'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$129/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$160/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$245/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$316/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$61

metrosto...rage.com

Metro Self Storage

8 sizes available

4.4

4038 Sunrise Hwy Oakdale, NY

13.9 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$39/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$79/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$120/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$259/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$249/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$515/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$400/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$115/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$39

metrosto...rage.com

Metro Self Storage

12 sizes available

5.0

105 Old Riverhead Rd Westhampton Beach, NY

12.4 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$55/ mo

5'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$65/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$219/ mo

10'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$219/ mo

10'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$229/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$160/ mo

10'Ă—12'

starting at

 

$285/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$240/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$675/ mo

10'Ă—23'

starting at

 

$1039/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$1129/ mo

11'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$69/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$55

  • Find spaces where you can drive up to load and unload items from a vehicle or truck.

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

7 sizes available

4.8

2626 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY

13.1 mi

similarly priced

4'Ă—4'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$109/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$155/ mo

10'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$193/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$211/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$374/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$421/ mo

4'Ă—4' starting at

$56

selfstor...ogue.com

Self Storage of Quogue Inc

7 sizes available

4.7

2 Quogue Plaza Trl Quogue, NY

14.5 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$94/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$164/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$254/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$299/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$359/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$425/ mo

20'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$475/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$94

primesto...roup.com

Prime Storage

12 sizes available

4.8

98 Depot Rd Westhampton Beach, NY

12.3 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$170/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$214/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$347/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$569/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$570/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$776/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$829/ mo

10'Ă—40'

starting at

 

$1041/ mo

12'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$234/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$268/ mo

15'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$859/ mo

20'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$324/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$170

  • Find storage for all your Shirley business needs like inventory, equipment, boxes, tools, etc.

primesto...roup.com

Prime Storage

18 sizes available

4.3

21 Hammond Rd Centereach, NY

11.6 mi

similarly priced

4'Ă—4'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

4'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$74/ mo

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$92/ mo

5'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$115/ mo

5'Ă—35'

starting at

 

$318/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$163/ mo

10'Ă—6'

starting at

 

$180/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$271/ mo

10'Ă—12'

starting at

 

$308/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$319/ mo

10'Ă—18'

starting at

 

$339/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$362/ mo

10'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$492/ mo

10'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$530/ mo

12'Ă—12'

starting at

 

$290/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$214/ mo

20'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$285/ mo

20'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$787/ mo

10'Ă—30' starting at

$530

unit2go.com

Unit2Go

30 sizes available

4.4

11900 Oregon Rd Cutchogue, NY

26.1 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$69/ mo

5'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$109/ mo

5'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$49/ mo

6'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$59/ mo

6'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$139/ mo

7'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$189/ mo

8'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$69/ mo

8'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$239/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$119/ mo

10'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$189/ mo

10'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$169/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$194/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$319/ mo

10'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$319/ mo

10'Ă—27'

starting at

 

$489/ mo

12'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$215/ mo

12'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$339/ mo

12'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$349/ mo

12'Ă—25'

starting at

 

$399/ mo

12'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$639/ mo

13'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$119/ mo

14'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$225/ mo

14'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$439/ mo

14'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$399/ mo

14'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$619/ mo

15'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$282/ mo

15'Ă—16'

starting at

 

$329/ mo

16'Ă—9'

starting at

 

$235/ mo

16'Ă—20'

starting at

 

$539/ mo

16'Ă—30'

starting at

 

$649/ mo

14'Ă—9' starting at

$225

uhaul.com

U-Haul Moving & Storage

3 sizes available

532 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

9.4 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$105/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$150/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$225/ mo

10'Ă—10' starting at

$225

  • Find self storage spaces that allow you to access your items at any time of day.

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

2 sizes available

4.9

730 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY

18.9 mi

similarly priced

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$217/ mo

15'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$164/ mo

15'Ă—5' starting at

$164

saintjam...rage.com

St James Self Storage Inc

11 sizes available

4.4

75 Arlington Ave St James, NY

16 mi

similarly priced

5'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$69/ mo

9'Ă—22'

starting at

 

$285/ mo

10'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$129/ mo

10'Ă—7'

starting at

 

$140/ mo

10'Ă—10'

starting at

 

$189/ mo

10'Ă—12'

starting at

 

$206/ mo

10'Ă—15'

starting at

 

$195/ mo

10'Ă—22'

starting at

 

$290/ mo

12'Ă—5'

starting at

 

$135/ mo

12'Ă—22'

starting at

 

$348/ mo

22'Ă—8'

starting at

 

$225/ mo

5'Ă—5' starting at

$69

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units
open view of an empty garage

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

Shirley does not currently have any listings available with security cameras

Find drive-up storage
Interior-Access Storage Units
row of indoor storage lockers

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

Shirley does not currently have any listings available with no stairs as a feature

Find indoor storage units
Vehicle Storage Units
view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in Shirley is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Shirley

Despite the fact that traditional storage options are common in Shirley, New York, Neighbor storage often has lower-priced, close by and secure self storage.

If you'd like information about traditional storage units nearby, use the below list of self storage facilities for more details:

Extra Space Storage (4.7 miles)

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

Bayport Mini Storage (9.2 miles)

915 Montauk Hwy Bayport, NY

iStorage Self Storage (7.9 miles)

257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

Extra Space Storage (9.2 miles)

970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY

Extra Space Storage (11.4 miles)

510 Johnson Ave Bohemia, NY

iStorage Self Storage (9 miles)

709 Church St Bayport, NY

Extra Space Storage (8.2 miles)

14 Francis Mooney Dr Ridge, NY

Storage R Us (5.8 miles)

192 Frowein Rd East Moriches, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage (10 miles)

640 Broadway Ave Holbrook, NY

Extra Space Storage (15.8 miles)

1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy Islandia, NY

StorQuest Self Storage (1.5 miles)

393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY

Extra Space Storage (10 miles)

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

Life Storage (8.2 miles)

500 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

Prime Storage (10.9 miles)

868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, NY

Cubesmart Self Storage (7.8 miles)

120 River Ave Patchogue, NY

Need self storage in Shirley?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 448-0855