Extra Space Storage in Bay Shore, NY

1775 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

(631) 210-6603

  • Monday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Tuesday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Wednesday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Thursday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Friday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Saturday

    9:00 am - 5:30 pm

  • Sunday

    Closed

Storage facility cost comparison

5×5

10×10

10×30

10×40

Extra Space Storage

Bay Shore, NY

$87

$120

--

--

Neighbor

18 storage spaces nearby

Extra Space Storage

North Babylon, NY (4 miles)

$78

$256

$779

--

Public Storage

West Babylon, NY (5 miles)

$88

$276

$837

--

Metro Self Storage

Oakdale, NY (7 miles)

$48

$166

$609

$609

About Extra Space Storage

Amenities & Features

Climate

  • Climate Controlled
  • Interior units

Access

  • Elevator

Security

  • N/A

Available Sizes

  • 10x5
  • 10x7
  • 10x8
  • 10x10
  • 10x15
  • 10x20
  • 10x25
  • 15x7
  • 20x8

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor is an online marketplace that connects those who have extra space with those in need of storage.
Learn more about why people loving storing with their Neighbors.

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Units available at nearby locations

5'×5' and up

starting at $14

See available units

10'×10' and up

starting at $50

See available units

10'×20' and up

starting at $50

See available units

Recommended storage units near Bay Shore

20 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Bay Shore, New York

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Bay Shore, New York

2.7 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

25 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Bay Shore, New York

25×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Bay Shore, New York

2.7 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in West Babylon, New York

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

West Babylon, New York

5.4 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Farmingdale, New York

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Farmingdale, New York

9.6 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Farmingville, New York

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Farmingville, New York

13.1 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

5 x 8 Basement in Manhattan, New York

5×8 Basement

Manhattan, New York

38.4 miles

Andrew's profile

Andrew P.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Mount Sinai, New York

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Mount Sinai, New York

17 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

5 x 5 Garage in Manhattan, New York

5×5 Garage

Manhattan, New York

37 miles

James's profile

James A.

Verified Host

25 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Miller Place, New York

25×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Miller Place, New York

19.5 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Garden City, New York

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Garden City, New York

17.7 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

10 x 20 Basement in Brooklyn, New York

10×20 Basement

Brooklyn, New York

37.5 miles

Preston's profile

Preston A.

Verified Host

12 x 12 Bedroom in Queens, New York

12×12 Bedroom

Queens, New York

29 miles

Jake's profile

Jake G.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Norwalk, Connecticut

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

Norwalk, Connecticut

25.5 miles

Publics's profile

Publics S.

Verified Host

12 x 12 Garage in Manhattan, New York

12×12 Garage

Manhattan, New York

37 miles

Paul's profile

Paul O.

Verified Host

12 x 12 Garage in Brooklyn, New York

12×12 Garage

Brooklyn, New York

39.3 miles

Jacob's profile

Jacob G.

Verified Host

12 x 22 Garage in New York, New York

12×22 Garage

New York, New York

39.2 miles

j's profile

j d.

Verified Host

18 x 50 Warehouse in New York, New York

18×50 Warehouse

New York, New York

36.7 miles

Boss's profile

Boss M.

Verified Host

58 x 25 Bedroom in Manhattan, New York

58×25 Bedroom

5.0

Manhattan, New York

38.2 miles

Harsh's profile

Harsh B.

Verified Host

Can't find what you are looking for?

Bay Shore, NY has 10+ nearby options.

View nearby spaces

Nearby Facilities

Prime Storage in Bay Shore
StorQuest Self Storage in Deer Park
Public Storage in Bay Shore
Life Storage in Bay Shore
Extra Space Storage in Brentwood
CubeSmart Self Storage in Deer Park
Life Storage in Deer Park
Simply Self Storage in Hauppauge
Extra Space Storage in Hauppauge
Manor Park Mini Warehousing in Deer Park
CubeSmart Self Storage in Brightwaters
America Safe & Sound in Hauppauge
CubeSmart Self Storage in North Babylon
Extra Space Storage in North Babylon
Extra Space Storage in Deer Park
Extra Space Storage in Islandia
Premier Storage Solutions in West Islip
Public Storage in West Babylon
Public Storage in Commack
Sunrise Storage in West Babylon
Metro Self Storage in Oakdale
StorQuest Self Storage in West Babylon
Extra Space Storage in Kings Park
U-Haul Storage at Bellemeade Avenue in Smithtown

Need self storage in Bay Shore?

Search the world’s largest vehicle and self storage marketplace for the cheapest, closest and safest car storage, RV storage, boat storage and trailer storage.

(385) 469-2248

Search storage